Education Minister Barišić Found Guilty of Plagiarizing His Research

By , 10 Jan 2017, 09:18 AM Politics
Education Minister Barišić Found Guilty of Plagiarizing His Research Source: N1

Share this:

According to the opinion of the Committee on Ethics in Science and Higher Education, Minister has plagiarized parts of text from Stephen Schlesinger.

According to unofficial reports, the Committee on Ethics in Science and Higher Education has adopted an opinion on the complaint by four scientists who accused Croatian Minister of Science and Education Pavo Barišić of plagiarism. The Committee found that Barišić had taken parts of a text of American philosopher Stephen Schlesinger while not quoting his sources, reports Jutarnji List on January 10, 2017.

Four scientists reported Barišić in 2011 for plagiarism in an article published in the journal Synthesis Philosophica. The complaint stated that Barišić plagiarized several parts of other people's works, books and Internet sources in his article in the English language “Does Globalization Threaten Democracy”, which was published in the second issue of the magazine in 2008. The complaint featured a comparative analysis of the controversial parts of the Barišić’s article and allegedly plagiarized parts of other people's works, which noted many similarities, such as taking ideas and formulations, and even literal copying from Wikipedia, without citing the author.

According to the complaint, Barišić took concepts from theorists Samuel P. Huntington, Carl Boggs and Stephen Schlesinger without mentioning them anywhere in his article, while he mentioned Robert A. Dahl in connection with just one sentence, although he allegedly copied a whole range of his ideas and formulations. In addition, complaints claimed that Barišić without citing sources took information from the Wikipedia entry on “Democracy”, together with a misspelled surname of political philosopher Francis Fukuyama, who is both in his article and in Wikipedia’s entry written as Fukayama.

While the charges regarding Barišić’s plagiarism of Schelesinger are deemed undeniable and it is obvious that the passage was plagiarized, the Committee did not agree about other issues.

Members of the Committee reportedly concluded that two other complaints did not contain such obvious cases of plagiarism, and that compared to the original texts Barišić’s work is very similar, even in the order of ideas, but it was not possible to establish that it was plagiarized. The conclusion of the Committee in the case of Schlesinger was expected, given that the respected expert for international relations Stephen Schlesinger confirmed last year that he had received an apology from Croatian Minister of Science Pavo Barišić due to copying parts of his text from the internet without citing the author.

“It is clear that the text in the journal Synthesis Philosophica was plagiarism, but at least there were footnotes in my part of his essay. In any case, I have accepted Barišić’s apology”, said Schlesinger last year. Minister Barišić still categorically denied that he plagiarised anybody.

Accusations for plagiarism against Barišić were first widely reported three months ago, when it was announced that he would become Croatian Education and Science Minister. Due to this and other issues, he was immediately described as the weaskest link in the new government.

From Croatia with Madness

Croatia Traffic Info

  • Traffic is heavy on most of the roads leading towards the coast and towards the interior of the country (on most of the motorways A1 Zagreb-Split-Ploče, A2 Zagreb-Macelj, A3 Bregana-Lipovac, on the A7 Rupa-Diračje), on the Krk bridge in both directions and on most of the roads in the coastal area, especially near Crikvenica, Novi Vinodolski, Zadar, Šibenik, Dubrovnik, on the section Split-Omiš-Makarska and between Klek and Zaton Doli through Neum. The state road DC59 between Kistanje and Ivoševci is closed due to a wild fire. on the A1 Zagreb-Split-Ploče there is some queueing traffic between the rest area Vukova Gorica and Karlovac at the toll station Lučko 4 km in direction Zagreb, at Demerje 1 km in direction coast traffic is occasionally queueing between Lučko and Karlovac on the A2 Zagreb-Macelj on the A2 Zagreb-Macelj westbound traffic is occasionally stopped at the junction Krapina due to heavy traffic at the toll station Trakošćan the queue is 5 km long, at the toll station Krapina 2 km at the border crossings Kaštel and Plovanija in Istria 6 km queueing traffic towards Slovenia at the Matulji junction: occasional hold-ups are possible in both directions on the A7 Rupa-Diračje at the junction Rupa occasional hold-ups towards the border crossing Pasjak on the state road towards the border crossing Pasjak 7 km at the toll station Rupa 1,5 km in direction Slovenia at the border crossing Rupa 500 m in direction Slovenia on the Krk bridge occasionally in both directions Driving restrictions: freight vehicles exceeding 7,5 t - Saturday, 19th of August; 4AM - 2PM - Sunday, 20th of August; 12AM - 11PM Sections of the roads closed due to roadworks: -the DC29 from Novi Golubovec (DC29, DC35) -the DC502 Smilčić-Pridraga state road -ŽC5042 Višnjan-Tićan. Traffic is regulated by traffic signals/one road lane is free only: -on the DC1 state road in Knin, on the section Sučević-Otrić in Otrić -on the state road DC2 in Vukovar, (Kudeljarska and Priljevo street) -on the state road DC66 Pula- Raša bridge -on the state road DC206 Valentinovo-Petrovsko. With the sunny and dry weather, more and more cyclists and motorists are on the roads. Other vehicles (such as cars or trucks) should look carefully for bicyclists before turning left or right, merging into bicycle lanes and opening doors next to moving traffic. Check your mirrors and be aware of blind spots before turning. While at a stop sign or red light, make a complete stop in order to let bikers pass, and check for unseen riders. Respect the right of way of bicyclists because they are entitled to share the road with you. Cyclists are not immune to traffic violations: pay attention to red lights and practice arm signaling!
    Read more
  • Due to heavy traffic during the tourist season longer wait times are possible on most border crossings with Slovenia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Serbia and Montenegro.
    Read more
  • The catamaran line Pula-Mali Lošinj-Zadar is suspended due to bad weather conditions.
    Read more

Interview of the week

Photo galleries and videos